The Church and Purgatory: A Theological and Systematic Balance

• Emmanuel Actor Oyewole, PhD

  Dominican University, Ibadan

  Author

• Timothy O. E. Popoola, PhD

  Dominican University, Ibadan

  Author

This study investigates the doctrine of purgatory within the context of Christian theology, especially within the purview of Roman Catholic teaching, so as to establish a theological and systematic balance. The persistent theological tension between modern ecumenical dialogue and traditional Catholic dogma on purgatory, which is often misinterpreted, is the motivation for this paper. The objective of this work is to examine the historical, doctrinal, and scriptural bases of purgatory and evaluate its significance in contemporary ecclesiological contexts. The misrepresentation of purgatory and conceptual ambiguity in both pastoral and academic settings is where the problem lies. Hence, this study provides a structured theological synthesis that upholds tradition with an invitation for ecumenical discourse as it seeks to bridge the gap. This work employed a qualitative theological analysis, using historical-critical methods for systematic theology and scriptural interpretation for doctrinal coherence. Primary ecclesiastical documents such as Council of Trent decrees, Catechism of the Catholic Church, writings of Church Fathers, and mother theological scholarship are used as instruments for data collection. Findings reveal that purgatory is not a mere peripheral concept; rather, it serves as a bridge between divine mercy and justice, which are deeply rooted in the Church’s soteriological framework. The paper concludes by asserting that a balanced understanding of purgatory reinvigorates both the Church’s pastoral care for the faithful departed and its eschatology. This study therefore, recommends encouraging ecumenical engagements to reframe and demystify purgatory in the light of the shared Christian hope, and fostering catechesis on eschatological doctrines.

• PDF